Fingerprint scanner not working after running recalibration software

After replacing my screen I was getting the "Can't use fingerprint sensor. Visit a repair provider" Message. I was able to run the recalibration software fastboot mode on the phone using Windows 10. No driver install| required. After just one reboot I could access the fingerprint settings and create a new fingerprint. After that, the phone does not ever recognize the fingerprint and requires a pattern to unlock/verify. I have tried recreating several new fingerprint scans with different fingers. Nothing fixes this problem. Any advice before I contact iFixit for a second new replacement screen?