The system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate
crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:
I just purchased a used MacBook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement battery installed and noticing some odd behavior with the SMC?
First the MacBook was shutting down within seconds after logging with the battery still at 100%, 90% and even 60% (running off battery). So I thought it was an SMC issue so I let the battery drain and calibrate 3 times, reset the SMC with a with and without the power cable plugged in.
I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery was not able to either supply a healthy amount of power to keep the MacBook on? Or maybe just too new?
The SMC reset seemed to help with calibrating the battery but it still just shutsdown before hibernating when the battery reaches a low point. I get a notification to plug in the power cable though which is good! So there's been a little progress in that sense where the Macbook only shuts down due to actual low battery instead of a fully charged one. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular pattern reading?
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop though? And I'm still not sure if the MacBook can stay powered on after the login screen without a power cable. I'm almost too afraid of trying again out of disappointment. : (
[image|3348634]
Attached is a reading of the battery after it is fully charged and plugged into the power cable. When running the terminal with the prompt log shows
--predicate 'eventMessage contains "Previous shutdown cause"' --last 24h I get the number 0 which means "***0*** Battery disconnected. Check power supply/battery on a laptop, or the power supply for a Mac without a battery. On a laptop, the Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power." and also -60 if I let the battery get to 0% without plugging in the power cable
"***-60*** Battery fully drained. Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."
The system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate
crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:
-
I just purchased a used Macbook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement battery installed and noticing some odd behavior with the SMC? [br]
-
[br]
-
First the Macbook was shutting down within seconds after logging with the battery still at 100%, 90% and even 60% (running off battery). So I thought it was an SMC issue so I let the battery drain and calibrate 3 times, reset the SMC with a with and without the power cable plugged in.[br]
-
[br]
-
I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery was not able to either supply a healthy amount of power to keep the Macbook on? or maybe just too new? ⏎[br]
-
⏎[br]
-
The SMC reset seemed to help with calibrating the battery but it still just shutsdown before hibernating when the battery reaches a low point. I get a notification to plug in the power cable though which is good! So there's been a little progress in that sense where the Macbook only shuts down due to actual low battery instead of a fully charged one. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular pattern reading? ⏎[br]
-
⏎[br]
-
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop though? And I'm still not sure if the Macbook can stay powered on after the login screen without a power cable. I'm almost too afraid of trying again out of disappointment. : (
+
I just purchased a used MacBook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement battery installed and noticing some odd behavior with the SMC?
+
+
First the MacBook was shutting down within seconds after logging with the battery still at 100%, 90% and even 60% (running off battery). So I thought it was an SMC issue so I let the battery drain and calibrate 3 times, reset the SMC with a with and without the power cable plugged in.
+
+
I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery was not able to either supply a healthy amount of power to keep the MacBook on? Or maybe just too new?
+
+
The SMC reset seemed to help with calibrating the battery but it still just shutsdown before hibernating when the battery reaches a low point. I get a notification to plug in the power cable though which is good! So there's been a little progress in that sense where the Macbook only shuts down due to actual low battery instead of a fully charged one. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular pattern reading?
+
+
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop though? And I'm still not sure if the MacBook can stay powered on after the login screen without a power cable. I'm almost too afraid of trying again out of disappointment. : (
[image|3348634]
+
Attached is a reading of the battery after it is fully charged and plugged into the power cable. When running the terminal with the prompt log shows
+
--predicate 'eventMessage contains "Previous shutdown cause"' --last 24h I get the number 0 which means "***0*** Battery disconnected. Check power supply/battery on a laptop, or the power supply for a Mac without a battery. On a laptop, the Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power." and also -60 if I let the battery get to 0% without plugging in the power cable
-
⏎[br]
-
Attached is a reading of the battery after it is fully charged and plugged into the power cable. When running the terminal with the prompt ⏎[br]
-
⏎[br]
-
log show --predicate 'eventMessage contains "Previous shutdown cause"' --last 24h⏎[br]
-
⏎[br]
-
I get the number 0 which means⏎[br]
-
, ⏎[br]
-
"***0***Battery disconnected.Check power supply/battery on a laptop, or the power supply for a Mac without a battery. On a laptop, the Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."⏎[br]
-
⏎[br]
-
and also -60 if I let the battery get to 0% without plugging in the power cable⏎[br]
-
⏎[br]
-
"***-60***Battery fully drained.Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."
+
"***-60*** Battery fully drained. Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."
The system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate
crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:
-
I just purchased a used Macbook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement battery installed and noticing some odd behavior with the SMC. [br]
+
I just purchased a used Macbook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement battery installed and noticing some odd behavior with the SMC? [br]
[br]
-
Laptop was first shutting down within seconds after booting up and logging with the battery still at 100%, 90% and even 60%. So I thought it was an SMC issue so I let the battery calibrate 3 times and reset the SMC with a completely dead battery with and without the power cable plugged in.[br]
+
First the Macbook was shutting down within seconds after logging with the battery still at 100%, 90% and even 60% (running off battery). So I thought it was an SMC issue so I let the battery drain and calibrate 3 times, reset the SMC with a with and without the power cable plugged in.[br]
[br]
-
I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery is still not able to either supply a healthy amount of power or maybe just too new? It is a genuine Apple replacement battery. ⏎[br]
+
I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery was not able to either supply a healthy amount of power to keep the Macbook on? or maybe just too new? ⏎[br]
⏎[br]
-
Whilst doing this entire process I noticed that when the battery reaches from anywhere to 10-0% it will just shut down instead of going into hibernate mode. So there's been a little progress after the calibrations where the Macbook only shuts down due to actual low battery instead of a fully charged one. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular pattern reading? ⏎[br]
+
The SMC reset seemed to help with calibrating the battery but it still just shutsdown before hibernating when the battery reaches a low point. I get a notification to plug in the power cable though which is good! So there's been a little progress in that sense where the Macbook only shuts down due to actual low battery instead of a fully charged one. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular pattern reading? ⏎[br]
⏎[br]
-
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop though?
+
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop though? And I'm still not sure if the Macbook can stay powered on after the login screen without a power cable. I'm almost too afraid of trying again out of disappointment. : (
[image|3348634]
+
+
⏎[br]
Attached is a reading of the battery after it is fully charged and plugged into the power cable. When running the terminal with the prompt ⏎[br]
⏎[br]
log show --predicate 'eventMessage contains "Previous shutdown cause"' --last 24h⏎[br]
⏎[br]
I get the number 0 which means⏎[br]
, ⏎[br]
"***0***Battery disconnected.Check power supply/battery on a laptop, or the power supply for a Mac without a battery. On a laptop, the Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."⏎[br]
⏎[br]
and also -60 if I let the battery get to 0% without plugging in the power cable⏎[br]
⏎[br]
"***-60***Battery fully drained.Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."
The system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate
crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:
-
I just purchased a used installed a new battery in my Macbook Mid 2015 and noticed some odd behavior with the SMC. Laptop would shut down within seconds after the login screen and sometimes even while at 100%, 90% and even 60%. I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery is not able to either supply a healthy amount of power or maybe just too new? It is a genuine Apple replacement battery. ⏎[br]
+
I just purchased a used Macbook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement battery installed and noticing some odd behavior with the SMC. [br]
+
[br]
+
Laptop was first shutting down within seconds after booting up and logging with the battery still at 100%, 90% and even 60%. So I thought it was an SMC issue so I let the battery calibrate 3 times and reset the SMC with a completely dead battery with and without the power cable plugged in.[br]
+
[br]
+
I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery is still not able to either supply a healthy amount of power or maybe just too new? It is a genuine Apple replacement battery. ⏎[br]
⏎[br]
-
I made sure to reset the SMC, Calibrated the battery 3 times and tried several other things to fix this issue. So far it hasnt shut down while running off the battery but noticed that when it reaches from anywhere to 10-0% it will just shut down instead of going into hibernate mode. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular routine reading? ⏎[br]
+
Whilst doing this entire process I noticed that when the battery reaches from anywhere to 10-0% it will just shut down instead of going into hibernate mode. So there's been a little progress after the calibrations where the Macbook only shuts down due to actual low battery instead of a fully charged one. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular pattern reading? ⏎[br]
⏎[br]
-
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop? Wondering if anyone can help me progr[image|3348634]am my laptop somehow where it won't just shut down before hibernating. ⏎[br]
+
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop though?
+
+
[image|3348634]
+
⏎[br]
Attached is a reading of the battery after it is fully charged and plugged into the power cable. When running the terminal with the prompt ⏎[br]
⏎[br]
log show --predicate 'eventMessage contains "Previous shutdown cause"' --last 24h⏎[br]
⏎[br]
I get the number 0 which means⏎[br]
, ⏎[br]
"***0***Battery disconnected.Check power supply/battery on a laptop, or the power supply for a Mac without a battery. On a laptop, the Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."⏎[br]
⏎[br]
and also -60 if I let the battery get to 0% without plugging in the power cable⏎[br]
⏎[br]
"***-60***Battery fully drained.Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."
The system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate
crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:
-
Having the same issue on my Macbook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement Battery. At first my Macbook was shutting down immediatly right after the log in screen after turning on my unit. I made sure to calibrate the battery a few times and even reset the SMC to see if the problem still continued. Today is the first day the problem hasn't happened after calibrating my battery 3 times in a row (letting it completely discharge, reseting the smc and booting back up with power cable until 100%, leave on with power cable for another 2hrs, unplug and let it drain back down to 0%). So my problem now is the system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate I just get a message the battery is low and then it will eventually shut down instead of going into hibernate. I wonder if I should reset SMC at 5% instead of after the battery is fully drained? Or at 100%? With or without the power cable in? How can I program or reprogram my macbook to hibernate instead of completely shutting down?
+
I just purchased a used installed a new battery in my Macbook Mid 2015 and noticed some odd behavior with the SMC. Laptop would shut down within seconds after the login screen and sometimes even while at 100%, 90% and even 60%. I was able to login fine with a power cable plugged in but it seems the battery is not able to either supply a healthy amount of power or maybe just too new? It is a genuine Apple replacement battery. ⏎[br]
+
⏎[br]
+
I made sure to reset the SMC, Calibrated the battery 3 times and tried several other things to fix this issue. So far it hasnt shut down while running off the battery but noticed that when it reaches from anywhere to 10-0% it will just shut down instead of going into hibernate mode. Maybe I just need to keep using it so the battery and SMC can develop a more regular routine reading? ⏎[br]
+
⏎[br]
+
I can't imagine this to be good for my laptop? Wondering if anyone can help me progr[image|3348634]am my laptop somehow where it won't just shut down before hibernating. ⏎[br]
+
⏎[br]
+
Attached is a reading of the battery after it is fully charged and plugged into the power cable. When running the terminal with the prompt ⏎[br]
+
⏎[br]
+
log show --predicate 'eventMessage contains "Previous shutdown cause"' --last 24h⏎[br]
+
⏎[br]
+
I get the number 0 which means⏎[br]
+
, ⏎[br]
+
"***0***Battery disconnected.Check power supply/battery on a laptop, or the power supply for a Mac without a battery. On a laptop, the Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."⏎[br]
+
⏎[br]
+
and also -60 if I let the battery get to 0% without plugging in the power cable⏎[br]
+
⏎[br]
+
"***-60***Battery fully drained.Mac should hibernate before the battery becomes so discharged it is unable to shutdown correctly, therefore if you see this shutdown cause on a laptop it may indicate a hardware issue with the battery or with the battery controller for reading the charge. Try resetting the SMC by connecting the switched off computer to power, holding ⌃control+⌥option+⇧shift and pressing power."
The system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate
crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:
Having the same issue on my Macbook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement Battery. At first my Macbook was shutting down immediatly right after the log in screen after turning on my unit. I made sure to calibrate the battery a few times and even reset the SMC to see if the problem still continued. Today is the first day the problem hasn't happened after calibrating my battery 3 times in a row (letting it completely discharge, reseting the smc and booting back up with power cable until 100%, leave on with power cable for another 2hrs, unplug and let it drain back down to 0%). So my problem now is the system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate I just get a message the battery is low and then it will eventually shut down instead of going into hibernate. I wonder if I should reset SMC at 5% instead of after the battery is fully drained? Or at 100%? With or without the power cable in? How can I program or reprogram my macbook to hibernate instead of completely shutting down?
Having the same issue on my Macbook Pro Mid 2015 with a brand new Apple Replacement Battery. At first my Macbook was shutting down immediatly right after the log in screen after turning on my unit. I made sure to calibrate the battery a few times and even reset the SMC to see if the problem still continued. Today is the first day the problem hasn't happened after calibrating my battery 3 times in a row (letting it completely discharge, reseting the smc and booting back up with power cable until 100%, leave on with power cable for another 2hrs, unplug and let it drain back down to 0%). So my problem now is the system doesn't recognize or doesn't know when to hibernate I just get a message the battery is low and then it will eventually shut down instead of going into hibernate. I wonder if I should reset SMC at 5% instead of after the battery is fully drained? Or at 100%? With or without the power cable in? How can I program or reprogram my macbook to hibernate instead of completely shutting down?