crwdns2933423:0crwdne2933423:0
crwdns2918538:0crwdne2918538:0

crwdns2934243:0crwdne2934243:0 Nick and oldturkey03 crwdns2934247:0crwdne2934247:0

crwdns2947189:0crwdne2947189:0:

Is my MacBook Pro dead?

crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:

Apple MacBook Pro "Core 2 Duo" 2.8 17" Mid-2009 Specs

Identifiers: Mid-2009 17" - MC226LL/A* - MacBookPro5,2 - A1297 - 2329*

Thanks to forgive my approximate English, I'm French.

My Mbp 17" mid 2009 (A1297) doesn't start, the magsafe has the green light or orange when the battery is a bit empty, the lights on the battery say that it's charged, it had no accident like liquid spill and it didn't fall.

Those last months it started with some difficulty, I had to reset the SMC a few times before it would start, but it worked. And this time it didn't start up, it seems that there is no power.

I've tried every trick I found on the net and on Ifixit : reset the SMC, by-pass the SMC, tried to startup with the pads.

When I reset the SMC, the magsafe which is orange before becomes green for a few seconds and goes back to orange, so it seems that the SMC works !

I tried 2 magsafe, they both work.

Unfortunately I have no other battery to check and I'de like to avoid to buy a new one just to check and find that the problem is in the motherboard, because this battery seems to work, the leds light up when I push the button, and if I leave it connected after 1 day or 2 there are less leds working.

I don't know what else to try, anyone would have an idea ?

Thanks for your answers.

crwdns2866306:0crwdne2866306:0:

MacBook Pro 17" Unibody

crwdns2915684:0crwdne2915684:0:

open

crwdns2934251:0crwdne2934251:0:

+535568

crwdns2934245:0crwdne2934245:0 Ben Capehart

crwdns2947189:0crwdne2947189:0:

Is my MacBook Pro dead?

crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:

Apple MacBook Pro "Core 2 Duo" 2.8 17" Mid-2009 Specs
+
Identifiers: Mid-2009 17" - MC226LL/A* - MacBookPro5,2 - A1297 - 2329*
Thanks to forgive my approximate English, I'm French.
My Mbp 17" mid 2009 (A1297) doesn't start, the magsafe has the green light or orange when the battery is a bit empty, the lights on the battery say that it's charged, it had no accident like liquid spill and it didn't fall.
Those last months it started with some difficulty, I had to reset the SMC a few times before it would start, but it worked. And this time it didn't start up, it seems that there is no power.
I've tried every trick I found on the net and on Ifixit : reset the SMC, by-pass the SMC, tried to startup with the pads.
When I reset the SMC, the magsafe which is orange before becomes green for a few seconds and goes back to orange, so it seems that the SMC works !
I tried 2 magsafe, they both work.
Unfortunately I have no other battery to check and I'de like to avoid to buy a new one just to check and find that the problem is in the motherboard, because this battery seems to work, the leds light up when I push the button, and if I leave it connected after 1 day or 2 there are less leds working.
I don't know what else to try, anyone would have an idea ?
Thanks for your answers.

crwdns2866306:0crwdne2866306:0:

MacBook Pro 17" Unibody

crwdns2915684:0crwdne2915684:0:

open

crwdns2934245:0crwdne2934245:0 mayer

crwdns2947189:0crwdne2947189:0:

Is my MacBook Pro dead?

crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:

+Apple MacBook Pro "Core 2 Duo" 2.8 17" Mid-2009 Specs
+Identifiers: Mid-2009 17" - MC226LL/A* - MacBookPro5,2 - A1297 - 2329*
+
Thanks to forgive my approximate English, I'm French.
My Mbp 17" mid 2009 (A1297) doesn't start, the magsafe has the green light or orange when the battery is a bit empty, the lights on the battery say that it's charged, it had no accident like liquid spill and it didn't fall.
Those last months it started with some difficulty, I had to reset the SMC a few times before it would start, but it worked. And this time it didn't start up, it seems that there is no power.
I've tried every trick I found on the net and on Ifixit : reset the SMC, by-pass the SMC, tried to startup with the pads.
When I reset the SMC, the magsafe which is orange before becomes green for a few seconds and goes back to orange, so it seems that the SMC works !
I tried 2 magsafe, they both work.
Unfortunately I have no other battery to check and I'de like to avoid to buy a new one just to check and find that the problem is in the motherboard, because this battery seems to work, the leds light up when I push the button, and if I leave it connected after 1 day or 2 there are less leds working.
I don't know what else to try, anyone would have an idea ?
Thanks for your answers.

crwdns2866306:0crwdne2866306:0:

MacBook Pro 17" Unibody

crwdns2915684:0crwdne2915684:0:

open

crwdns2934245:0crwdne2934245:0 andynice

crwdns2947189:0crwdne2947189:0:

Is my MacBook Pro dead?

crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:

Thanks to forgive my approximate English, I'm French.

My Mbp 17" mid 2009 (A1297) doesn't start, the magsafe has the green light or orange when the battery is a bit empty, the lights on the battery say that it's charged, it had no accident like liquid spill and it didn't fall.

Those last months it started with some difficulty, I had to reset the SMC a few times before it would start, but it worked. And this time it didn't start up, it seems that there is no power.

I've tried every trick I found on the net and on Ifixit : reset the SMC, by-pass the SMC, tried to startup with the pads.

When I reset the SMC, the magsafe which is orange before becomes green for a few seconds and goes back to orange, so it seems that the SMC works !

I tried 2 magsafe, they both work.

Unfortunately I have no other battery to check and I'de like to avoid to buy a new one just to check and find that the problem is in the motherboard, because this battery seems to work, the leds light up when I push the button, and if I leave it connected after 1 day or 2 there are less leds working.

I don't know what else to try, anyone would have an idea ?

Thanks for your answers.

crwdns2866306:0crwdne2866306:0:

MacBook Pro 17" Unibody

crwdns2915684:0crwdne2915684:0:

open

crwdns2934251:0crwdne2934251:0:

-210425

crwdns2934245:0crwdne2934245:0 andynice

crwdns2947189:0crwdne2947189:0:

Is my MacBook Pro dead?

crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:

Thanks to forgive my approximate English, I'm French.

My Mbp 17" mid 2009 (A1297) doesn't start, the magsafe has the green light or orange when the battery is a bit empty, the lights on the battery say that it's charged, it had no accident like liquid spill and it didn't fall.

Those last months it started with some difficulty, I had to reset the SMC a few times before it would start, but it worked. And this time it didn't start up, it seems that there is no power.

I've tried every trick I found on the net and on Ifixit : reset the SMC, by-pass the SMC, tried to startup with the pads.

When I reset the SMC, the magsafe which is orange before becomes green for a few seconds and goes back to orange, so it seems that the SMC works !

I tried 2 magsafe, they both work.

Unfortunately I have no other battery to check and I'de like to avoid to buy a new one just to check and find that the problem is in the motherboard, because this battery seems to work, the leds light up when I push the button, and if I leave it connected after 1 day or 2 there are less leds working.

I don't know what else to try, anyone would have an idea ?

Thanks for your answers.

crwdns2866306:0crwdne2866306:0:

MacBook Pro 17" Unibody

crwdns2915684:0crwdne2915684:0:

open

crwdns2934251:0crwdne2934251:0:

+210425

crwdns2934245:0crwdne2934245:0 Walter Galan

crwdns2947189:0crwdne2947189:0:

Is my MacBook Pro dead?

crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:

Thanks to forgive my approximate English, I'm French.

My Mbp 17" mid 2009 (A1297) doesn't start, the magsafe has the green light or orange when the battery is a bit empty, the lights on the battery say that it's charged, it had no accident like liquid spill and it didn't fall.

Those last months it started with some difficulty, I had to reset the SMC a few times before it would start, but it worked. And this time it didn't start up, it seems that there is no power.

I've tried every trick I found on the net and on Ifixit : reset the SMC, by-pass the SMC, tried to startup with the pads.

When I reset the SMC, the magsafe which is orange before becomes green for a few seconds and goes back to orange, so it seems that the SMC works !

I tried 2 magsafe, they both work.

Unfortunately I have no other battery to check and I'de like to avoid to buy a new one just to check and find that the problem is in the motherboard, because this battery seems to work, the leds light up when I push the button, and if I leave it connected after 1 day or 2 there are less leds working.

I don't know what else to try, anyone would have an idea ?

Thanks for your answers.

crwdns2866306:0crwdne2866306:0:

-MacBook Pro 17" Unibody mid 2009 A1297
+MacBook Pro 17" Unibody

crwdns2915684:0crwdne2915684:0:

open

crwdns2934241:0crwdne2934241:0 andynice

crwdns2947189:0crwdne2947189:0:

Is my MacBook Pro dead?

crwdns2934249:0crwdne2934249:0:

Thanks to forgive my approximate English, I'm French.

My Mbp 17" mid 2009 (A1297) doesn't start, the magsafe has the green light or orange when the battery is a bit empty, the lights on the battery say that it's charged, it had no accident like liquid spill and it didn't fall.

Those last months it started with some difficulty, I had to reset the SMC a few times before it would start, but it worked. And this time it didn't start up, it seems that there is no power.

I've tried every trick I found on the net and on Ifixit : reset the SMC, by-pass the SMC, tried to startup with the pads.

When I reset the SMC, the magsafe which is orange before becomes green for a few seconds and goes back to orange, so it seems that the SMC works !

I tried 2 magsafe, they both work.

Unfortunately I have no other battery to check and I'de like to avoid to buy a new one just to check and find that the problem is in the motherboard, because this battery seems to work, the leds light up when I push the button, and if I leave it connected after 1 day or 2 there are less leds working.

I don't know what else to try, anyone would have an idea ?

Thanks for your answers.

crwdns2866306:0crwdne2866306:0:

MacBook Pro 17" Unibody mid 2009 A1297

crwdns2915684:0crwdne2915684:0:

open