Good morning,
That my friend, is very odd. If i were to guess it would be that you may have bought a 13" board?????? That doesn't make sense i know but this is drawing down to the oddities.
Open up your macbook and see if any of the board components are burned. Maybe your 85W requires an extra component that your current board doesnt support.
What i want you to do is to put the old board back in and try all the chargers and record which ones burn and which ones function. What you've likely found is some kind of odd QC between all the parts you've bought, which would be extremely unlucky.
Good luck :) and i'm here if you need anything