@safeabuck86 looks like the control for your thermostat. I am certain you can still find a repalcment. Let us know what the exact model number for your toaster is. You may have to jury-rig it to make one fit but that should not be an issue. you seem to have lots of room in the enclosure. Do an online search and check for something like "Bimetallic Heating Thermostat Temperature Switch"