Hi Carly. That plastic drain pump cover had a part number on it for me look at yours very closely) . It was DC94-03523A. I found it at sears part direct for around $ 35. Worked out fine. By the way - several months later my pump died too. I replaced my pump with an LG part that was clearly the same but didn't have the same part number. Spent only 25 on the LG pump. Seems they source from the same place even though they don't cross link the part numbers. Good luck on your repair.