I have the same issue, I replaced the old broken screen with the new one, but when I press the power button the device trying to load for 10-15 seconds then the screen becomes black. If I press the power button for a long time the screen powered on again showing the power off option, but I can't turn it off by pressing the power button again. If I reinstall again the old screen, it is working fine without any issue.
I have checked 4 new screens all of them having the same issue. Should I use specific replacement screen for model no. A1538 to get it work?