'''I think the problem might be in the OS. '''
You are apparently off to a normal start in the EFI stage but then something fails… what that might be is the "HD" could be damaged, or, more likely a damaged/corrupt OS.
Of late many macbook automagic shutdowns/white or black screens trace back to corrupted OS.
Try swapping the "HD" from one of the normal booting machines.
''If this answer is acceptable '''please remember to return and mark it'''.''